Cigar being rated:
|
Size
|
Flavor
|
CC
|
Ratings
|
Rated by:
|
CAO Brazilia Amazon
|
6.0" X 60
|
Full
|
N
|
94
|
JC
|
Comments: Hands down the best cigar I've ever smoked. Dark, oily wrapper. Perfect draw and impeccable construction. CAO has a winner in this one.
|
Bahia Robusto Maduro
|
5.0"X50
|
Full
|
CR
|
84
|
KC
|
Comments: Strong robust smoke. Nice construction. Hint of toasted nuts & expresso.
|
Estavan Cruz Short Cruz
|
4.0"X52
|
Full
|
D
|
87
|
JC
|
Comments: A great short smoke. Full flavored. Try this one. One of my favorites.
|
A. Fuente Don Carlos Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Med
|
D
|
90
|
KC
|
Comments: Medium strength with with plenty of creamy coffee flavor. Impeccable
construction. Loved it. Recommended.
|
Ashton VSG Illusion
|
6.5"X44
|
Full
|
D
|
88
|
JC
|
Comments: Highly recommended. Full flavored. A little on the expensive side.
|
CAO L'Anniversaire Cameroon-Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Med
|
N
|
86
|
JC
|
Comments: Loved it.! Box-pressed and smooth.
|
CAO L'Anniversaire eXtreme Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Full
|
N
|
90
|
JC
|
Comments: A strong and flavorful cigar. Will require some aging. Recommended.
|
CAO L'Anniversaire eXtreme Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Full
|
N
|
82
|
KC
|
Comments: Full flavor. Very strong, almost overpowering. A little rough but good flavor.
Needs some aging.
|
Mayorga Robusto Maduro
|
4.75"X50
|
Med
|
N
|
84
|
JC
|
Comments: High quality at an affordable price. This is a definite "Must Try".
|
Andros Corona Maduro
|
5.5"X46
|
Med
|
D
|
88
|
KC
|
Comments: Spicy and flavorful. Excellent construction. Highly recommended. Only
available in Maduro wrapper.
|
Perdomo Estate Seleccion Imperio
|
5.5"X48
|
Full
|
N
|
89
|
JC
|
Comments: Full-bodied but not over-powering. A joy to smoke.
|
Estavan Cruz Maduro Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Full
|
D
|
87
|
JC
|
Comments: A very nice stick. Even burn. Tasty Maduro wrapper. Recommended!
|
Macanudo Portofino
|
7.0"X34
|
Mild
|
D
|
69
|
JC
|
Comments: Tough draw. Too mild. Can't recommend.
|
Perdomo Reserve Rosado
5.0"X54
|
5.0"X54
|
Med
|
N
|
84
|
JC
|
Comments: A very nice cigar. I love the shape. A classic.
|
Puros Indios Rothschild
|
5.0"X50
|
Med
|
H
|
83
|
JC
|
Comments: I liked this one. Burns slow and even. Oily wrapper. Smooth and tasty.
|
Punch Punchito Perfecto
|
4.5"X50
|
Med
|
H
|
65
|
JC
|
Comments: A harsh and unpleasant cigar. Avoid this one.
|
CAO L'Anniversaire
Cameroon- Belicoso
|
6.0"X54
|
Med
|
CR
|
88
|
JC
|
Comments: Simply a wonderful brand. Highly recommended.
|
Flor De Oliva Grand Cameroon Churchill
|
7.0"X50
|
Med
|
N
|
86
|
JC
|
Comments: Inexpensive alternative to CAO. Very enjoyable. Box pressed.
|
Dos Rios Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Med
|
N
|
84
|
JC
|
Comments: I really like this one. With age it will only get better. Made by Perdomo.
|
Bahia Trinidad Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Med
|
N
|
79
|
JC
|
Comments: Box pressed. Has a slight harshness. Not my favorite.
|
La Perla Habana Maduro Torpedo
|
6.25"X52
|
Med
|
D
|
85
|
JC
|
Comments: Nicely constructed. Tasty maduro wrapper. Try this one. You'll like it.
|
Maya Maduro Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Full
|
H
|
78
|
JC
|
Comments: Sit down while smoking this powerhouse. Overpowering taste.
|
Mayorga Maduro Torpedo
|
6.0"X52
|
Med
|
N
|
86
|
JC
|
Comments: A good inexpensive cigar. Box pressed. Needs some humidor time.
|
Flor De Oliva Grand Maduro Churchill (Box-pressed)
|
7.0"X50
|
Med
|
N
|
85
|
JC
|
Comments: A great Maduro at a low price. Smooth from start to finish. Even burn.
|
Napa Reserve Corona
|
5.75"X42
|
Med
|
CI
|
85
|
JC
|
Comments: Wonderful cigar. Has many of the characteristics of a good Cuban.
|
CAO L'Anniversaire Maduro-Belicoso
|
6.0"X54
|
Med
|
N
|
88
|
JC
|
Comments: Great tasting Maduro. Smooth to the finish.
|
Lone Wolf Signature Pyramid
|
6.0"X52
|
Med
|
D
|
68
|
JC
|
Comments: Tasted like fresh lawn clippings. May get a little better with age.
|
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Box-pressed Toro Maduro
|
6.0"X52
|
Full
|
H/N/CR
|
85
|
JC
|
Comments: A full flavored powerhouse. If you like intense flavor, this is the one.
|
La Tradicion Perdomo Reserve #2
|
5.0"X54
|
Med
|
N
|
86
|
JC
|
Comments: A very smooth cigar. You won't be disappointed!
|
Pinar 1958 Series B
Pre-Embargo Cuban
|
5.0"X50
|
Med
|
CU/D
|
85
|
JC
|
Comments: Made from 50/50 mix of Cuban/Dominican filler. Wonderful cigar.
|
Hoja Cubana XXO Tony Borhani Epicure
|
6.0"X50
|
Full
|
CR
|
83
|
JC
|
Comments: Very tasty full-bodied stick. Even burn. Well constructed.
|
Punch Elite
|
5.25"X44
|
Med
|
H
|
82
|
JC
|
Comments: Good everyday smoke. Price is right.
|
La Luna LHB Robusto
|
5.0"X50
|
Med
|
U
|
80
|
JC
|
Comments:Good everyday smoke. Less than $1.00 each. Unbanded.
|
Indian Tabac Cameroon Legend Perfecto
|
5.0"X52
|
Med
|
D
|
85
|
JC
|
Comments: Flawless construction and burn. Perfect draw. Beautiful cigar!!
|